Case Law


Travelers Insurance Company of Canada v. CAA Insurance Company 2020 ONCA 382 Court of Appeal for Ontario, Lauwers, Paciocco and Fairburn JJ.A. June 15, 2020


Appeal by Travelers Insurance from a decision dismissing its appeal from an arbitrator’s decision requiring the appellant to reimburse the respondent CAA for the benefits CAA had paid to CAA’s insured and to assume responsibility for paying the benefits to her in the future. The claimant was catastrophically injured in an accident in Nunavut where she was temporarily employed. She was driving a Nunavut plated vehicle owned by the Government of Nunavut and covered by a Nunavut motor vehicle insurance policy issued by the appellant to the Government of Nunavut. Under that policy the claimant was entitled to Nunavut statutory accident benefits. The claimant, ordinarily resident in Ontario, owned a car plated in Ontario and insured by CAA. Under the terms of her Ontario insurance policy, the claimant was contractually entitled to claim Ontario statutory accident benefits from CAA. The arbitrator found that the appellant was an Ontario insurer because it was licensed to undertake automobile insurance in Ontario. He also found the appellant was bound by the power of attorney and undertaking, which it signed in 1964 and thus became an insurer in the province or territory where the claim was brought. ...

Young v. CRC Self-Help 2020 ONSC 1874 Superior Court of Justice, Divisional Court, Favreau J. March 26, 2020


The appellant was a veteran who suffered a workplace injury and whose only source of income was from Ontario Works. He was a tenant in building complex owned by the respondent, which provided affordable alternative housing for those hard to house. In 2016, the parties reached a mediated settlement in which the appellant was ordered not to post items or symbols of any kind in the common areas of the residential complex. In 2019, the respondent applied to the Landlord and Tenant Board ex parte to evict the appellant for breach of that order. The board made an eviction order in November 2019. The appellant requested a review, resulting in a stay of eviction. On January 21, 2020, the board confirmed the eviction and lifted the stay. The appellant did not move out of his unit by the deadline of February 1, but filed a review of the eviction order. On February 19, the appellant attended the board to discover that his review request had been denied the previous day. He returned to his unit to find that the sheriff’s office had executed the eviction and that the lock had been changed, resulting in the commencement of an appeal to the Divisional Court and a stay of the eviction order. The respondent refused to allow the appellant back into his unit. The appellant moved for an order to reinstate his tenancy pending the hearing of the appeal. ...

Roy v. Ottawa Capital Area Crime Stoppers et al. 2018 ONSC 4207 Superior Court of Justice, C. MacLeod J. July 5, 2018


The plaintiff found an unattended purse in a shopping mall and turned it over to a bus driver. The owner of the purse reported it to the police as stolen. The police obtained surveillance video of the plaintiff taking the purse and posted it on the Crime Stoppers website with a caption that referred to a “purse snatching” and described the plaintiff as a “suspect” who “stole a purse”. The plaintiff sued the police and Crime Stoppers for damages for libel and negligence. The defendants brought a motion for summary judgment dismissing the claims. ...

Scarlett v. Belair Insurance Company Inc. et al. 2015 ONSC 3635 Superior Court of Justice, Divisional Court, June 5, 2015


The insurer took the position that the insured’s predominant injury was a minor injury as defined in s. 3 of the Statutory Accident Benefits Schedule (“SABS”), so that he was entitled to claim a maximum of $3,500 in medical and rehabilitation benefits pursuant to s. 18(1) of SABS and would not be entitled to claim for attendant care benefits pursuant to s. 14. The parties applied for arbitration. As a preliminary issue, the insurer brought a motion for an order that the insured was suffering from minor injuries and was therefore limited in the benefits he could claim. The arbitrator determined that the insured did not fall under the Minor Injury Guideline — Superintendent’s Guideline No. 2/10 and was entitled to medical and rehabilitation benefits beyond the maximum prescribed in s. 18 of the SABS. The director’s delegate allowed the insurer’s appeal. The insured brought an application for judicial review of that decision. ...

Soboczynski et al. v. Beauchamp et al. 2015 ONCA 282 April 23, 2015


The parties entered into an agreement of purchase and sale which contained an “entire agreement” clause. Before the transaction closed, the defendant vendors completed a seller property information statement (“SPIS”) in which they stated that the property was not subject to flooding and undertook to inform the plaintiff purchasers of any important changes to the information contained in the SPIS. The defendants failed to inform the plaintiffs of a pre-closing basement flood. After the closing, the basement flooded again, and the plaintiffs found out about the earlier flood. They sued the defendants for damages for negligent misrepresentation. The trial judge found that the entire agreement clause in the agreement of purchase and sale acted as a bar to the action. The Divisional Court allowed the plaintiffs’ appeal. The defendants appealed. ...